train track

Can You Get Your Money Back From a Deepfake Scam in Canada?

If a scammer fools you into sending money, can you get it back from the bank? In Canada right now, the honest answer is: probably not. If you’re 88 and your savings are on the line, or you have a parent who is, that’s worth knowing before something happens.

A recent case shows how this works in practice.

What happened

According to a report on Yahoo Finance Canada, Ralph Moore, a retiree in Qualicum Beach, B.C., came across an online video in May 2025. It appeared to show Prime Minister Mark Carney endorsing a state-backed investment scheme. It was a deepfake.

Over the next 10 months, Moore sent scammers more than $450,000. He did it through online transactions and repeated visits to his local TD branch.

The bank did notice something. It questioned some of the transactions, warned him about scams and temporarily restricted his account. But it never stopped the money from going out, and it hasn’t returned any of it. His daughter, Leslie Herrndorf, told CBC’s Go Public, “They knew this was unusual behaviour.” TD declined to discuss the case, citing client confidentiality.

Why the bank doesn’t have to pay

It comes down to how the money left the account. The article, citing a federal regulatory analysis published in June, lays it out like this:

  • Card fraud. If someone uses your credit or debit card details without your permission, your liability is capped at $50 unless you were grossly negligent.
  • Everything else. Banks are legally allowed to put the full loss on the customer for unauthorized Interac e-Transfers, wire transfers and international funds transfers. They can also hold you responsible for payments you approved after being deceived. Investment scams are named specifically.

That last point is the one that matters here. If you were tricked into sending the money yourself, the law treats it very differently from someone stealing your card number. The article says a CBC Go Public investigation heard from more than 30 victims, and in almost every case the bank blamed the customer.

How common is this?

The numbers in the article are large:

  • Canadians reported $704 million in fraud losses to the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre (CAFC) in 2025. That’s about 300% more than in 2020.
  • The CAFC estimates only 5% to 10% of fraud is ever reported.
  • Canadians under 50 are more likely to be targeted, but people over 50 lose more money.
  • The Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments (OBSI) opened 1,815 fraud investigations in 2025, nearly double the year before. Its ombudsman, Sarah Bradley, told a Senate committee that only about one in five ended with any recourse.

Will the rules change?

Not in the way most people would hope. The U.K. has required banks to reimburse scam victims by default since October 2024, unless the bank can prove gross negligence. A Léger survey of 1,519 adults, commissioned by the consumer group Option consommateurs, found 87% of respondents think Canadian banks should do the same. Even the U.K. system has a cap, though. Radio-Canada puts it at roughly $160,000 per claim, which is well below Moore’s loss.

The Canadian Bankers Association told Go Public that making banks pay won’t stop fraudsters and could backfire on everyday customers and the wider economy.

Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne told CBC the government is building a national anti-fraud strategy, but he didn’t commit to making banks cover losses. What’s proposed is more control for you over your own account. Banks would have to:

  • get your express consent before turning on e-Transfers, wires or global money transfers;
  • let you switch those features off;
  • wait until the next business day to apply limit increases they can’t verify;
  • report fraud data to the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada.

The rules are set to take effect July 1, 2027. Features already active on existing accounts won’t need fresh consent. So if you bank today, changing those settings is up to you.

Does this apply to you?

Ask yourself three things:

  • Can you, or someone in your family, send e-Transfers or wires from a phone or computer?
  • Are the transfer limits higher than you’d ever really need?
  • Would an older relative tell anyone before sending a large amount?

If any answer is yes, a plan is worth making. Nothing in the source suggests this is only a problem for the very old. The article says people over 50 lose more money overall, which is why I’d start with parents and grandparents.

What to do today

  1. Call your bank and ask which transfer features are active on your accounts. Turn off or cap anything you don’t use. If you’ve never sent a wire, you probably don’t need wires switched on.
  2. Treat any investment pitch from a politician or celebrity video as a red flag. That’s exactly how this case began. A real government doesn’t sell investments through a clip on social media.
  3. Talk to older relatives about deepfakes. A deepfake can be a convincing video. It can also be a voice that sounds like someone you love. Make sure they know that what they see and hear online can be faked.
  4. Set a family rule: check in before any unusual transfer goes out. It should be a rule everyone agrees to in advance, not something you spring on someone mid-crisis. Make it apply to everyone, so it isn’t aimed at one person. A call to a second family member costs a few minutes.
  5. Agree on a way to verify a family emergency call. This isn’t from the article, but it’s standard advice: pick a code word that only your family knows, and agree that anyone asking for urgent money has to say it. If they can’t, hang up and call the person back on the number you already have.

In my work as a SOC analyst, the pattern I’d point to is simple. Scams rely on pressure, secrecy and speed. Your defence is anything that adds a pause and brings in a second person. The code word and the check-in rule both do that.

Signs something has already gone wrong

The source describes one case, so these are general warning signs, not a checklist from it:

  • Someone is making repeated trips to the bank or sending several transfers to the same new destination.
  • They’re talking about a “special” investment and getting defensive when you ask questions.
  • They’ve been told to keep it quiet, or the bank has already warned them and they went ahead anyway.
  • Savings are dropping and there’s no clear explanation.

In Moore’s case, the losses ran for 10 months. Noticing early matters.

If you’ve already been scammed

The article gives these steps:

  1. Call your bank immediately.
  2. Report it to the CAFC and to local police.
  3. Put your complaint to the bank in writing. The bank has 56 days to respond. After that, you can escalate to OBSI for free.

Know what OBSI can and can’t do. It can recommend up to $350,000 in compensation, but its recommendations aren’t binding on banks. That’s still worth pursuing, but it isn’t a guarantee. Given that only about one in five OBSI fraud cases ended with any recourse, I wouldn’t count on it either.

The article puts it plainly: until Ottawa decides who carries the cost of fraud, the strongest protection is the one you set up yourself. Lawyer Alexandre Plourde, of Option consommateurs, says “It’s time to act.”

Sources

Featured image: Image by FunkyFocus from Pixabay.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *