An invoice shows up from a supplier you’ve paid many times. Same company name, same kind of order. But the banking details are different. Do you pay it?
That’s the question that cost one business near Salmon Arm $24,299. It’s worth ten minutes of your time now, because the fix is a process, not software.
What happened in the Shuswap
According to CFJC Today’s report, a Shuswap business told Salmon Arm RCMP on Oct. 15 that it had received what it believed was an invoice from a supplier it knew. The invoice carried a new account number, institution number and transit number for the payment. The business paid, and the money was gone: $24,299.
One detail in the RCMP’s Nov. 16 news release stood out to me. Officers went to the bank of the account holder and learned the scammers were possibly moving the stolen money without the real account owner knowing. In plain English, the account that received the payment may belong to someone who has no idea it’s being used. So “it’s a real account at a real bank” tells you nothing about whether the payment is legitimate.
The file is still under investigation. The report doesn’t say how the invoice arrived or whether the money was recovered, so I won’t guess at either.
How to tell if this could happen to you
Ask yourself these questions:
- Do you pay suppliers, contractors or subcontractors by bank transfer or direct deposit?
- Can one person receive an invoice, change the payee’s banking details and send the payment?
- If an invoice arrives with new banking details, is there a set routine for checking it, or does whoever’s at the desk just handle it?
If you answered yes to the first and the second, or “no routine” to the third, you’re exposed. That describes most small firms. It isn’t a character flaw. Small teams are busy, and a familiar name on an invoice gets treated as proof.
What to do today: the callback rule
This is the single most useful control, and it costs nothing. Any request to change where a supplier gets paid gets verified by phone before a dollar moves.
- Don’t use the contact details on the invoice or the change request. If the invoice is fake, the phone number or email on it may be fake too. Replying to the message that asked for the change just puts you back in touch with whoever sent it.
- Call a number you already trust. Use a number from your own records: an earlier contract, a past paid invoice you filed, or the supplier’s official website that you look up yourself.
- Talk to a person you know. Ask for your usual contact, or someone in accounts receivable. Tell them you’ve received new banking details and ask them to confirm them out loud.
- Read the details back. Confirm the institution number, transit number and account number against what’s on the invoice. Even one wrong digit means you stop and ask more questions.
- Write it down. Note the date, who you spoke to, the number you called and who on your side did the checking. Put it in the supplier’s file.
Pressure to skip this step is a warning sign in itself. If anyone says the change is urgent, or that a call isn’t necessary, that’s a reason to slow down. That’s general fraud-prevention advice and it holds up well.
Bank-change controls you can set up in an afternoon
The callback rule works better when it’s backed by a few simple internal rules. None of this needs special tools. A spreadsheet and a written page will do.
- Keep one list of verified banking details. For each regular supplier, record the institution, transit and account numbers you’ve confirmed. Pay from that list, not from whatever the latest invoice says.
- Treat any change as a special event. A change to that list needs a completed callback and a written note of who verified it.
- Require two people. One person does the callback and updates the details. A different person approves the payment. If you’re a one-person business, wait a day and look at it again, or ask your bookkeeper or accountant to be the second pair of eyes.
- Flag changed details on the first payment. Whenever the account differs from last time, someone should stop and check before the money goes out. Your bank may also have its own payment-verification options. Ask them what’s available for your account type.
- Tell your suppliers how you work. A short note saying “we confirm all banking changes by phone before paying” helps. Real suppliers will understand. It also lets them know to expect your call.
- Tell everyone who touches invoices. That includes your bookkeeper, your part-time admin and whoever covers when you’re away. The rule only works if it’s the same for everyone, including when you’re travelling.
Also tidy up the basics. Strong, unique passwords and multi-factor authentication on the email accounts that receive invoices make it harder for someone to read your payment conversations. I can’t tell you from this report whether that played any part in the Shuswap case, because the report doesn’t say. But in general, a scammer who knows who you pay and when is far more convincing.
Signs something already went wrong
- A supplier asks why they haven’t been paid for an invoice you believe you settled.
- You notice that an invoice you paid had banking details that differ from past payments.
- A supplier says they never sent a change request you acted on.
- A payment went to a name or account you don’t recognize in your banking records.
When an analyst reviews a suspected payment fraud, the first questions are always the same: when was the money sent, to which account, and what message triggered the change? So gather the invoice, the message it came with, and your payment confirmation before you make any calls.
If you think you’ve been caught
- Call your bank right away. Tell them you sent a payment to what may be a fraudulent account. Speed matters in these cases. I can’t promise a bank can pull the money back, but the earlier they know, the more options exist.
- Contact the real supplier on a number you trust, so they know their name is being used.
- Report it to police and the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre. The RCMP urged anyone who believes they’ve been a victim, or knows someone who has, to report it to the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre online or by phone at 1-888-495-8501.
- Keep everything. Don’t delete the invoice, the message or any call notes. Investigators will want them.
- Change passwords on the email account that received the invoice, and turn on multi-factor authentication if it isn’t already on.
If your bank, your accountant or an IT provider can help you review how invoices and payments move through your business, that’s a good use of an hour. The goal is that no single message can redirect your money.
The short version
A new set of bank numbers on a familiar supplier’s invoice is a question, not an instruction. Call a number you already trust, confirm the details with a person, write it down, and have a second person approve the payment. Do that and you’ve closed the gap that cost a Shuswap business $24,299.


